Justice Douglas' Environmental Legacy, featuring Judge McKeown
On April 18, 2024, the legal and environmental communities gathered in the Ceremonial Courtroom of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois to discuss Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas’s enduring legacy.
The event, hosted by Perkins Coie LLP and Northwestern Pritzker School of Law, featured a captivating presentation by Hon. M. Margaret McKeown of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, centered on her book Citizen Justice: The Environmental Legacy of William O. Douglas, Public Advocate, and Conservation Champion.
Justice Douglas: The Pioneering Environmental Advocate
Justice William O. Douglas served on the U.S. Supreme Court from 1939 to 1975. He left an indelible mark on the law and environmental advocacy during his tenure. Known for his active participation in conservation efforts, Douglas was often called “Wild Bill,” a nickname reflecting his dynamic approach to his personal and professional life. His environmental activism extended beyond the judiciary as he engaged in lobbying, formed committees, and even led protest hikes to safeguard natural spaces. His role in creating the C&O Canal National Historical Park, through direct advocacy and engaging the public, exemplifies his dedication to environmental conservation.
Douglas’s love for nature was deeply personal. His childhood experiences influenced him in the wilderness around Yakima, Washington, where he sought refuge and healing. This connection to nature shaped his views and judicial philosophy. He believed in preserving wilderness for its intrinsic value and necessity for the human spirit.
Insights from Judge McKeown
Judge Margaret McKeown shared her insights into Douglas’s complex character and environmental legacy in her book presentation. McKeown, who has served on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit since 1998, highlighted Douglas’s environmental law and advocacy approach. She portrayed him as a multifaceted figure—sometimes controversial yet always driven by a deep commitment to conservation. Douglas’s advocacy was not confined to his judicial role; he was actively involved in environmental movements, utilizing his public profile to influence and mobilize public opinion and policy toward ecological preservation.
Judge McKeown emphasized Douglas’s strategic use of his position to engage in what she termed “dissenting on the road,” where he used his public influence to campaign against developments that threatened natural landscapes. One of his notable efforts was his opposition to a proposed highway through the C&O Canal, which he successfully thwarted by inviting influential stakeholders on a hike to experience its natural beauty firsthand, leading to its designation as a national historical park.
A Legacy of Environmental Jurisprudence
Douglas’s environmental legacy is also evident in his jurisprudence. His opinions often reflected his belief that the Constitution should protect minority rights and remove governmental overreach, themes that also permeated his environmental advocacy. In his view, it cannot be regained once wilderness is lost, a perspective that fueled his relentless defense of natural spaces.
His dissent in the Sierra Club v. Morton case illustrates his environmental philosophy. Douglas argued for granting legal standing to natural objects, a revolutionary idea that shifted the legal perspective towards a more ecocentric approach to environmental law. Though this idea has not been widely adopted in U.S. courts, it influenced environmental legal thought and demonstrated Douglas’s forward-thinking approach.
The event provided attendees with a comprehensive understanding of Douglas’s environmental contributions, seen through the lens of both his judicial work and his public advocacy. It served not only as a reflection on his achievements but also as an inspiring call to continue advocating for protecting and preserving natural environments.
Justice Douglas’ Environmental Legacy Sparks a Continuing Dialogue
The event’s highlight was the interview conducted by Hon. Virginia Kendall, which explored the lasting impacts of Justice Douglas’s environmental advocacy on current legal challenges and the ongoing dialogue concerning the judiciary’s role in societal issues. This discussion underscored the relevance of Douglas’s legacy in today’s environmental struggles and judicial ethics.
Following the enlightening talk, the attendees participated in a reception and book signing with Judge McKeown, which provided an opportunity for deeper interaction and discussion about the themes presented. The event honored Justice Douglas’s contributions and fostered a rich exchange of ideas among legal professionals, scholars, and environmental enthusiasts, encouraging ongoing engagement with the crucial issues at the intersection of law and environmental stewardship.
This gathering was more than just a lecture; it was a vibrant platform for continuing the dialogue about the vital role of the judiciary in advocacy and conservation, inspired by the pioneering spirit of Justice William O. Douglas.
Do you want to stay involved with the Federal Bar Association Chicago Chapter? Explore our upcoming events and educational opportunities for attorneys!
